Skip to content

Beyond Consensus: Protocols as Digital Institutions

TalkMartin Harrahan
Beyond Consensus: Protocols as Digital Institutions

Martin Harrahan (a teaching fellow at Southeast Technological University in Ireland) presents a protocol school workshop demonstrating an LLM-powered pipeline that transcribes and clusters the Summer of Protocols YouTube corpus into 'foundational' and 'aggregated' ideas, which can then be loaded as context to get chatbots to answer in protocol-studies terms rather than narrow computer-science definitions. He then walks participants through using an LLM persona ('Kevin the dinner host') to roleplay a chosen protocol and test it against the ten properties from Josh Stark's 'Unreasonable Sufficiency of Protocols' framework (e.g. defensibility, mortality, hardness), showing how conversational steering can reveal whether a protocol resists capture or can gracefully die out.

Related resources

Talk

Divergent Protocols: A Speculative Protocol for Cultural Convergence Zones

Nicolás Madoery presents 'divergent protocols' as a counter-model to standard protocols that converge toward homogenization, arguing that AI and robotics now function as infrastructure (not tools) through which culture becomes 'liquid' and infinitely re-versioned. Drawing on examples like AI-generated Argentine folklore, a dancing folk robot, and his PIACH framework for cultural organizations, he proposes protocols that preserve diversity by naming what is lost, keeping source names, and leaving room for noise rather than optimizing transmission.

Nicolás Madoery

Lecture

Beyond Consensus - Protocols as Digital Institutions - Martin Harrigan

Martin Harrigan, a lecturer and teaching fellow at SETU in Ireland, presents a method for using LLMs to study protocols: first building an LLM context file by transcribing and clustering ideas from the entire Summer of Protocols YouTube channel, then using that context plus a 10-property framework from 'The Unreasonable Sufficiency of Protocols' to roleplay protocols (like his 'Kevin the dinner host' example) and test properties such as defensibility, mortality, and legitimacy. He walks through building prompts, meta-prompting, and steering LLM conversations to demonstrate these properties, while noting weaknesses like circular reasoning and the difficulty of generalizing from a single instantiation.

Martin Harrigan

Lecture

Protocol Art II - Primavera De Filippi & Felix Beer

Primavera De Filippi leads a seminar on protocol art, working through audience case studies (role-playing games, choreography, Yanis Xenakis scores, PostSecret, Pak's Merge/Censored) to test the boundaries between protocol-as-tool, protocol-as-medium, and mere mimetic/meme art. She then presents two archetypal case studies, Oli Plus and Plantoid, analyzing distributed authorship, asynchronous collaboration, DAO-based governance, the limits of copyright versus personality rights, automated royalty systems, community roles, and the temporal/evolutionary nature of protocol-based artworks.

Primavera De Filippi, Felix Beer