Skip to content

Beyond Consensus: Protocols as Digital Institutions

TalkMartin Harrahan
researcherpractitioner
Beyond Consensus: Protocols as Digital Institutions
Open resource →

Martin Harrahan (a teaching fellow at Southeast Technological University in Ireland) presents a protocol school workshop demonstrating an LLM-powered pipeline that transcribes and clusters the Summer of Protocols YouTube corpus into 'foundational' and 'aggregated' ideas, which can then be loaded as context to get chatbots to answer in protocol-studies terms rather than narrow computer-science definitions. He then walks participants through using an LLM persona ('Kevin the dinner host') to roleplay a chosen protocol and test it against the ten properties from Josh Stark's 'Unreasonable Sufficiency of Protocols' framework (e.g. defensibility, mortality, hardness), showing how conversational steering can reveal whether a protocol resists capture or can gracefully die out.

Topics

fictionhardness-joshua-starks-definitionllm-generated-protocol-studies-context-pipelinemeta-prompting-and-context-window-engineeringprotocolsresearchroleplaying-protocols-with-llms-as-a-sparringanalysis-techniquetechnologyten-properties-of-a-good-protocol-constrained-generative-learnable-legible-ludic-stewardable-defensible-evolvable-mortal-legitimatetown-hall

Related resources

Talk

The State of Climate Protocols

Cory Levenson (Corey Levenson), an engineer and climate tech consultant previously with Regen Network, surveys the state of carbon dioxide removal (CDR) protocols, distinguishing 'closed system' pathways like direct air capture and biochar (easy MRV, high cost) from 'open system' pathways like enhanced rock weathering and ocean alkalinity enhancement (cheaper but harder to quantify due to attribution challenges). He details emerging data protocols—including the Carbon Data Open Protocol, Cascade's ERW Data Query, and Carbon to Sea's Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement Data Protocol—and argues the field should adopt community-governed standards bodies (like OBO Foundry or schema.org's science working group) rather than letting registries like Isometric capture scientific protocol development.

Cory Levenson

Talk

The Infinite Game of Poetry: Protocols for Living, Listening, and Transcending the Rules

Poet and technologist Robert Peake presents a framework for poetry as a form of protocol and 'protocoling,' arguing that poetry is an infinite, unwinnable game defined by Marvin Bell's dictum: 'learn the rules, break the rules, make up new rules, and break the new rules.' Drawing on Gödel's incompleteness theorem, Bertolt Brecht, and examples like William McGonagall's disastrous verse versus ChatGPT-generated poetry, Peake distinguishes first-order protocols (grammar, form) from second-order 'protocoling' (the recursive, self-breaking evolution of rules), framing poetry as a compression algorithm that uses words to transcend words.

Robert Peake

Talk

AI as Normal Technology

Arvind Narayanan presents his paper/book 'AI as Normal Technology,' arguing against superintelligence narratives by applying innovation-diffusion theory (invention, innovation, diffusion stages) to AI, contending that societal adoption is bottlenecked by slow organizational, business-model, and institutional adaptation rather than by the pace of capability gains. In discussion with Venkatesh Rao, they connect this to protocol theory, framing workflows, business models, and context engineering practices as new 'protocols' that must be invented, while Rao draws analogies to naval warfare tactics, printing-press literacy, and the hardness/mud distinction from Josh Stark's work to explain why protocol adoption is inherently slow but durable.

Arvind Narayanan, Venkatesh Rao