Skip to content

Capital Enclosure for Software Commons

PaperTrent Van Epps

Van Epps argues that entities extracting profits from software commons like Linux and Ethereum have the greatest incentive and capacity to co-opt them, analyzing how common-pool resources operate according to internal logics distinct from capital accumulation. The paper examines the structural tension between the anti-rival nature of digital goods and the enclosure mechanisms through which commercial actors capture value from collaborative software ecosystems.

Related resources

Article

Protocols for Business 2026 Review: The Year of the Agent

As AI agents increasingly operate autonomously in business contexts without waiting for human approvals, organizations must rely on inherited legal and procedural frameworks—from agency law to audit trails—to maintain coherence rather than assuming either business-as-usual or complete organizational rupture. The piece argues that AI's integration represents a radical transformation that builds upon, rather than breaks from, centuries of established practices around delegation, authority, and accountability.

rafa, Sachin Benny, Matthew McDowell-Sweet

Talk

Group Brains: Minds Made of People

Kaliya Young presents her Protocol Institute-funded research on the IETF as a 'group brain' — a durable collective cognition combining a memory substrate (the data tracker, RFC series, mailing lists) with a human 'knowing' culture (rough consensus, birds-of-a-feather sessions, sortition-based leader selection) that together produce capacities no individual member holds. She extends the framework to Wikipedia and DAOs as comparative cases, introduces the concept of a 'group membrane' (who's in/out and how boundaries harden toward power), and argues AI should augment rather than replace human group cognition, positioning group-level alignment as a missing middle between individual and humanity-wide AI alignment debates.

Kaliya Young

Talk

Markets and the Journey to Neutrality

Nicholas Fett traces the history of market neutrality from 1889 Oklahoma land runs and Adam Smith's moral sentiments through Keynes, the Mont Pelerin Society, and into crypto, arguing that protocols designed to be neutral (Bitcoin's decentralization, Ethereum's 'crops' ethos) inevitably get captured by economic incentives like mining and block-builder centralization. He uses the 'tunnel' and 'one more lane' analogies to argue that building for neutral principles without a defined societal goal leads to outcomes divorced from original intentions, and that protocol designers must instead encode explicit purpose rather than chase an unattainable neutral equilibrium.

Nicholas Fett