Skip to content

Guest Talk with Kyle Mathews | Designing for Soft Protocols: A Discord Bot Workshop

TalkKyle Mathews
Guest Talk with Kyle Mathews | Designing for Soft Protocols: A Discord Bot Workshop

Kyle Mathews, introduced by Venkatesh Rao (referred to as 'vanet'), led a hands-on workshop distinguishing 'hard protocols' (rigid, software-enforced, testable like Greenhouse's hiring flow) from 'soft protocols' (governing, influence-based, running partly in human 'wetware' like Twitter's emergent norms). Participants broke into small groups to design a Discord bot for bookmarking/sharing links within the Summer of Protocols community, producing user stories around prioritization, auto-tagging, digests, and feeds, followed by reflections (notably from David Lang and Cara) questioning whether such categorization tools would actually be adopted or whether the exercise merely reinforced existing Discord-centric work patterns.

Related resources

Talk

Protocol Town Hall with Yancey Strickler | When the Means Justify the Ends

Yancey Strickler, co-founder of Kickstarter, recounts Metalabel's two-year journey building crypto-based infrastructure for creative 'culture labels' inspired by punk record labels and the Royal Society, and how repeated crises (the Gitcoin/Vitalik NFT frenzy, Pepe coin gas spikes, and a wallet drain) led the team to go on a 'crypto diet' and ultimately launch Metalabel with zero blockchains underneath, borrowing crypto's values (decentralized identifiers, open data, shared financial outcomes) while prioritizing end-user experience over ideological means. He argues crypto culture often lets 'the means justify the ends,' making it a poor 'major' but potentially a good 'minor' within a broader post-platform, protocol-literate design space, a point Venkatesh Rao extends with his 'brains, trains, and vibes-mobiles' metaphor.

Yancey Strickler

Talk

Reality and Realism in Generation

Neilson Koerner-Safrata (introduced as Nelson Bershad, working at World Labs) argues that photorealistic image and video generation functions as 'a protocol for knowing'—that creating a photoreal image or 3D world from a single photo demonstrates a form of knowledge about reality, inverting the historical arrow from reality-to-realism into realism acting back on reality. He traces this through his own tools (image-to-3D-world generation with physics and sound, camera-roll 'telepathy' search) and historical precedents like Muybridge's chronophotography, Duchamp's response to it, Ed Catmull's hand animation, and AlexNet, concluding that the same technology deepening our computational grasp of reality is simultaneously destroying the shared trust in photorealism as a stable representation of the real.

Neilson Koerner-Safrata

Talk

Don't Cross the Lines: Mazes as Minimal Protocols

Daniel Schmidt argues that mazes are a minimal formal instantiation of protocols, not just a metaphor, using his own maze-drawing history and games to illustrate concepts like hard vs. soft protocols (physical walls vs. crossable paper lines), scale-entangled vs. scale-lined navigation, and stigmergic memory. He demonstrates an ant colony pheromone simulation, a multiplayer infinite maze with shareable 'pebble' markers, a maze-design platform separating protocol-author from protocol-navigator with heatmaps of friction points, and an art-gallery maze as medium. Venkatesh Rao joins to explain his 'clockless clock' maze, a topological map of thought-space (rat/goat/crow vertices) designed by Schmidt to represent arrested development and spiraling toward nirvana.

Daniel Schmidt, Venkatesh Rao