Skip to content

Guest Talk w/ Christina Dunbar-Hester | Directing Signals: Of Politics and Protocols

TalkChristina Dunbar-Hester
researcherpractitioner
Guest Talk w/ Christina Dunbar-Hester | Directing Signals: Of Politics and Protocols
Open resource →

Christina Dunbar-Hester (USC, Science and Technology Studies) draws on her three books—Low Power to the People, Hacking Diversity, and Oil Beach—to examine protocols as 'terms of relating' that both open up new associations and enforce control, using Langdon Winner's framework that technologies encode order and politics. She traces this through 1990s-2000s pirate/low-power FM radio activism and community Wi-Fi ('cantennas'), gender exclusion and feminist server/code-of-conduct interventions in FLOSS communities, and the Port of Los Angeles/Long Beach as a site where standardized shipping protocols produce 'envirotechnical' dependencies and violence (pollution, whale strikes) hidden behind frictionless-flow imagery.</br>She closes by distinguishing protocols (which create hard material/standardized handoff points) from merely 'culturally disciplining' practices like crypto-dancing or feminist server principles, and argues analysts must attend to both material and ideational levels of protocols, their recurring maintenance needs, and how local changes do or don't scale to systemic ones.

Topics

cultural-discipline-vs-hard-coded-protocolenvirotechnical-infrastructure-and-maintenancefeminist-servers-and-codes-of-conduct-in-floss-communitiesgovernanceguest-talkslow-power-fm-radio-activism-and-community-wifiprotocol-watchingprotocolsprotocols-as-terms-of-relating-opening-vs-control

Related resources

Talk

The Indelible Importance of Illegibility

Patrick Atwater, innovation program manager at the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, argues that protocols exist simultaneously as documented formalisms and undocumented implicit norms, using case studies from a neighborhood park, bridge/infrastructure permitting, and track-2 diplomacy to illustrate this gap. He proposes practical strategies for navigating illegible terrain—black-boxing unknowns, cultivating domain-expert practitioners as guides, and lightweight fieldwork logging (e.g., a 'protocol watching' Notion database)—and shares a real example of a water utility valve project where jurisdictional coordination revealed pseudo-official knowledge and unwritten norms.

Patrick Atwater

Article

Trust by Protocol

Estonia's internet voting system represents a deliberate engineering of trust through protocol design, where digital procedures replace the legibility and visibility of traditional polling stations. By making the voting process itself a sophisticated yet understandable protocol, Estonia demonstrated that legitimacy in elections can be transferred from physical ritual to cryptographic procedure.

Jason Collins

Article

Disentangling the State of Climate

Cory Levinson surveys the current landscape of climate protocols, tracing how carbon markets and DeFi have collided since 2023, with projects like KlimaDAO absorbing millions of carbon credits into blockchain form and Regen Network expanding into biodiversity markets. The piece examines how these protocols are attempting to create durable market mechanisms for environmental assets despite fundamental challenges in traditional carbon crediting.

Cory Levinson