Skip to content

Plenary Talk - 2024 Protocol Symposium

TalkTim Beiko, Venkatesh Rao
researcheracademic
Plenary Talk - 2024 Protocol Symposium
Open resource →

Tim Beiko and Venkatesh Rao open the 2024 Protocol Symposium by recapping Summer of Protocols' two-year evolution, from testing whether 'protocols' form a coherent cross-domain field to this year's focus on applied stewardship, tensions (tradeoff plus conflict), and workshops like the Singapore and Edge Esmeralda pop-ups. Venkatesh then presents three orienting frameworks for the Symposium—the 'technological Tangled Bank,' the 'Erdos-Whitehead protocol age,' and the 'kit space of civilization'—arguing protocols are best understood as a literacy for seeing technology's relation to humans and environment rather than a technology class itself.

Topics

erdos-whitehead-protocol-agegovernancekit-space-of-civilizationorganizationsprotocolssummer-of-protocols-program-structure-and-research-clusterssymposium-2024technological-tangled-banktensions-tradeoff-conflict-as-a-framework-for-protocol-stewardship

Related resources

Talk

Salon II: ARC Regenerative Communities - 2024 Protocol Symposium

Kaliya Young and 'day' present research into the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) as a case study in regenerative governance, tracing its origins from the 1969 ARPANET through the 1992 governance crisis that shifted power from Vint Cerf's 'kitchen cabinet' IAB to open working groups organized around 'rough consensus and running code.' They map IETF practices—nomcom's randomized leadership selection, open RFC documentation, dispatch meetings, and ritualized in-person gatherings—onto three pattern languages (Group Works, Wise Democracy, and Social Permaculture) to argue that openness, transparency, and voluntariness are structural necessities, not limitations, for sustaining a healthy digital commons.

Kaliya Young, day

Talk

Governance Axioms

Eric Alston presents a framework of five recurring 'governance axioms' for protocol design—incomplete rules, governance-as-conflict, mechanical concentration of authority, asymmetric incentives from shared resources, and the transparency-privacy tradeoff—arguing these tensions can never be designed away, only managed through mechanisms like killswitches, veto-gates, and tiered amendment rules. Drawing on his experience advising Cardano's constitution, DAOs, and peace processes, Alston contends that 'incomplete rules' mean norms and discretion inevitably fill gaps left by any formally encoded protocol, and that durable systems require 'dynamic fidelity'—credible commitments combined with constrained capacity for adaptation rather than either permanent rigidity or unchecked flux.

Eric Alston

Talk

Open Social Protocols: A Commons-Based Protocol Layer

Jose Leal (with Scott Clearwater) presents Open Social Protocols, a framework built on Needs (recurring coordination conditions) around which communities publish, fork, and adopt Protocols rather than collapsing into single fixed agreements. He describes 'bridging protocols' that let multiple competing protocols for the same need coexist and interoperate, built atop the AT Protocol and a 'Common Ground' layer, citing examples like Morning Star Farms and Buurtzorg as organizations already operating this way without naming it 'protocol'.

Jose Leal, Scott Clearwater