Skip to content

S04E01 - New Nature

TalkTimber
S04E01 - New Nature

Timber, managing director of the newly formed Protocol Institute, opens Season 4 ('New Nature') by outlining the season's focus on AI and protocols, previewing upcoming guests (Denise Hearn, Sriram Krishnan, Kyle Matthews, Danny Ryan, Rohit Krishnan, Tanya). He then argues for a distinction between Safety-1 (minimizing accidents to zero) and Safety-2 (maximizing successful operations per accident, per Erik Hollnagel), applying Hollnagel's 'dynamic non-event' and efficiency-thoroughness trade-off (ETTO) concepts to critique mainstream AI alignment discourse as overly focused on existential risk rather than practical, bottom-up safety protocols.

Related resources

Talk

Reality and Realism in Generation

Neilson Koerner-Safrata (introduced as Nelson Bershad, working at World Labs) argues that photorealistic image and video generation functions as 'a protocol for knowing'—that creating a photoreal image or 3D world from a single photo demonstrates a form of knowledge about reality, inverting the historical arrow from reality-to-realism into realism acting back on reality. He traces this through his own tools (image-to-3D-world generation with physics and sound, camera-roll 'telepathy' search) and historical precedents like Muybridge's chronophotography, Duchamp's response to it, Ed Catmull's hand animation, and AlexNet, concluding that the same technology deepening our computational grasp of reality is simultaneously destroying the shared trust in photorealism as a stable representation of the real.

Neilson Koerner-Safrata

Talk

Don't Cross the Lines: Mazes as Minimal Protocols

Daniel Schmidt argues that mazes are a minimal formal instantiation of protocols, not just a metaphor, using his own maze-drawing history and games to illustrate concepts like hard vs. soft protocols (physical walls vs. crossable paper lines), scale-entangled vs. scale-lined navigation, and stigmergic memory. He demonstrates an ant colony pheromone simulation, a multiplayer infinite maze with shareable 'pebble' markers, a maze-design platform separating protocol-author from protocol-navigator with heatmaps of friction points, and an art-gallery maze as medium. Venkatesh Rao joins to explain his 'clockless clock' maze, a topological map of thought-space (rat/goat/crow vertices) designed by Schmidt to represent arrested development and spiraling toward nirvana.

Daniel Schmidt, Venkatesh Rao

Article

Disentangling the State of Climate

Cory Levinson surveys the current landscape of climate protocols, tracing how carbon markets and DeFi have collided since 2023, with projects like KlimaDAO absorbing millions of carbon credits into blockchain form and Regen Network expanding into biodiversity markets. The piece examines how these protocols are attempting to create durable market mechanisms for environmental assets despite fundamental challenges in traditional carbon crediting.

Cory Levinson