Protocol Town Hall with David Lang | Standards Make the World

TalkDavid LangDecember 14, 2023

David Lang presents his Summer of Protocols research on standards-making, drawing on his experience co-founding OpenROV and later developing the Bristlemouth underwater connector standard at Sofar Ocean. He argues standards fall into distinct types (safety, interoperability, performance, contractual) and traces three historical waves of standards-making per Yates and Murphy's 'Engineering Rules,' proposing that a 'disruptive model' of standards creation—where outsiders build working solutions first and backfill institutional approval later, as seen with CubeSats, MIDI, and BioBricks—is replacing the traditional top-down consortial model.

Topics

bristlemouth-connector-standard consortial-vs-disruptive-standards-processes cubesat-as-standards-analogy disruptive-standards-making-model governance protocols research researcher-salon technology types-of-standards-safety-interoperability-performance-contractual

Related resources

Talk

Psychological Safety I & II

Timber Stinson-Schroff argues that AI's workplace effects should be studied through occupational health frameworks rather than existential-risk AI safety, proposing 'cognitive ergonomics' as a better term than 'psychological safety' since it emphasizes chronic, long-term pathologies (like carpal tunnel from typewriters) over acute incidents. Drawing on the safety-one/safety-two distinction from traditional safety literature, Stinson-Schroff advocates crowdsourcing a database of AI usage hazards and pathologies—such as the 'yes man problem' from fast LLM responses and speech pattern changes—toward an eventual diagnostic manual, while cautioning against liability blind spots given the slow, second-order mechanisms by which these harms emerge.

Timber Stinson-Schroff

Talk

Trust Experience Glitches: AI Agents, Delegated Autonomy, and Legitimacy

Helena Rong (Assistant Professor at NYU Shanghai, director of the Protopolis Lab) presents a taxonomy of 'trust experience glitches'—six failure modes (agency assertion, epistemic camouflage, delegation ambiguity, opacity at scale, cascading autonomy, revocation failure) drawn from a 167-incident dataset of agentic AI failures. She argues these ruptures expose a 'consequence reception problem' where autonomous agents lack a stable body to bear accountability, and proposes that governance must shift from ex-post legal remedies toward upstream protocol primitives (capability-based permissions, provenance tracking, action-class legibility, circuit breakers, revocability) as the 'traffic lights' of the agentic web.</summary>

Helena Rong

Lecture

Designing Digital Worlds Communities, Protocols, AI, and Power - Andrés Monroy Hernández

Andrés Monroy-Hernández and Soyeon (So-young) outline a Princeton course on 'designing digital worlds,' tracing a lineage from Elinor Ostrom's commons governance and Yochai Benkler's commons-based peer production to today's decentralized social media protocols (ActivityPub, AT Protocol, Nostr, Farcaster), arguing each architecture encodes distinct political trade-offs around identity, curation, and infrastructure power. So presents her research on 'governance frictions' between federated communities and proposes design concepts like 'governance nutrition facts,' 'trust bubbles,' and an 'issue bulletin' to help fediverse moderators coordinate across incompatible norms.</br>

Andrés Monroy-Hernández